When you and your brother both grow up playing the same sport, it’s a safe bet that a pretty heated sibling rivalry will develop. And though you both may eventually grow up to become mature adults, that rivalry never really dies. Perhaps that’s why, despite having two rings of his own, Peyton Manning’s younger brother Eli couldn’t bring himself to smile even a little bit for his Super Bowl–winning big bro.
Of course, TV cameras caught the precise moment Eli’s old tendencies kicked in and that sent Twitter uses running to their phones and PCs to create hot viral content for your amusement. Below are some of our favorite Twitter moments reacting to Eli’s non-reaction.